Returning karate to its original purpose for self defence and self improvement.

Why I Prefer Kata, Instead of Kata?

There are two common Kanji for Kata, 型 and 形.

The first Kanji signifies suffering above ground, and indeed this is fitting for some methods of practicing Kata.

Methods where you keep going, pushing, sweating, and panting to hone your technique and train your body so that when the time comes it will work.

To me, however, this is just one way, and not, by all means, the only way.

You can practice Kata slow, fast, with power, without power, in tension and without tension.

You can do single sections repeatedly, you can do the Kata using only the top or the bottom half.

That is how versatile Kata is as a training tool.

The most versatile aspect of Kata is in how we adapt it to ourselves.

You see the second Kanji, which represents water taking on the form of the container, means that Kata can take on the form of whatever context it is in, standing, on the ground, long or short range.

It can also take on the form that best suits ourselves, our capabilities, and our best attributes.

If you understand how to read Kata you will see that it is not so literal in its meaning. It is not saying that when you put the Kata into use that you must do it exactly as you practised, but rather that you should use the lessons and principles that it taught you.

In Dave Lowry’s book Sword and Brush: The Spirit of the Martial Arts’ there is a beautiful description of his thoughts on Kata, and how the Kanji, 形, can represent the shadow of a window lattice, imposed on the floor as light streams through the window. The shadow is not the window, but it is in the form of the window.

So yes, Kata can be a punishing and gruelling way of practising Karate.

But I think, more importantly, it is the form in which you wish to use it that matters the most.

As Bruce Lee, creator of the style-less Jeet Kun Do, said “Be water, my friend”.

6 responses to “Why I Prefer Kata, Instead of Kata?”

  1. Jamie Gray avatar
    Jamie Gray

    Great post Ben! I have my own process of teaching (solo form) kata that incorporates 5 stages to align the kata with the individuals body to get the best and most natural fuild, strong, dynamic, impactive and complete kata which is unique (to that person) and less punishing on joints but faster and more effecrive.Very few people want to change the way they do kata prefferring the ‘sport’ style where everyones kata looks the same so well done for highlighting this.

    Jamie

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      Thanks Jamie. I completely agree with your training methods. First and foremost we must aim to protect ourselves, and then others. How can we do either of those if we are destroying our bodies from training? Self protection and development is a mindset that we must cultivate in the Dojo.

      Like

  2. Crystal avatar
    Crystal

    The background on the kanji for kata is very interesting, as is how you can interpret them metaphorically. Thank you for sharing!

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      Thanks for reading and commenting. Just trying to offer a varied perspective. ;-)

      Like

  3. Great article in which you clearly demonstrated the common occurrence of kanji being pronounced the same way but, written differently to depict a different meaning, and then tying it to your philosophy of study that I and surely others can relate. Really a great article.

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      Thanks very much J. I was inspired by Dave Lowry’s book years ago and it only seemed to make sense to me recently.

      Like

Leave a comment

Who’s the Writer?

Ben teaches his students from over 20 years of experience in Karate, the latest in supplementary training, advice on lifestyle health, diet and nutrition, and a personal creativity towards applied Karate practice.