Returning karate to its original purpose for self defence and self improvement.

How many Sensei does it take to make a Karateka?

Your Sensei is your guide, your teacher, your font of wisdom and knowledge.

They contain all there is to know and possess all the skills to pass it on to you.

They have transcended the mere form of a human and now sit…. Alright I’ll stop.

You get the point. 

This is what some feel their Sensei is to them. A person that needs no questioning and contains all the answers.

Sure, if you’re at the beginning of your Karate journey then why would you need to question or look outside of your current Dojo.

But you know they are human right? Flesh and blood, like you and me.

They may have put in more years of practice and know things you have not yet learned but they cannot contain all there is to know.

They ain’t superman – who also happens not to be infallible!

So if the answer is not One Sensei to make a Karateka, how many are needed?

In truth, as many as needed for any individual.

There are factors such as what goals the Karateka seeks, what they are looking to learn and discover and what stage of development they are currently in.

But let me make a distinction.

This it isn’t just a case of being taught at the odd class or seminar by different Sensei; perhaps of the same Style, association or culture.

This is where you embark on having a different Sensei for a longer period of time, because both of you need to learn how best to continue your journey. This cannot be done in a day.

There is a strong trend today to not deviate far, or at all, from the hand that has provided.

Dishonour and disrespect and other such feelings get planted with such ideas of learning from someone else.

And yet, historically, many of the famous and greatest Karateka have had at least 2 or more Sensei in their lifetime – even from different styles and schools of martial arts.

I am not even going to list them because it would take far too long and would require an interconnecting piece of string going all over the place to show it.

Plus, there are plenty of sources out there already doing that job.

What’s the benefit?

In a nutshell – different perspectives and ideas of how to implement the same principles. From this we not only gain some more knowledge, but also reinforce the knowledge from our previous Sensei.

Does it mean saying goodbye for good to your first Sensei? – not at all, unless of course their ego takes too much of a knock and they lock the door on you – because how could anyone else be able to teach and know Karate like them?

When is the right time to make a move?

It is hard to say. Perhaps after a period of time where you feel that your improvements are very incremental.

Usually this means that you know the basic movement and how to implement it to the best of your current ability, and your Sensei cannot help you much more in “perfecting” the technique.

This means that anything your new Sensei teaches you won’t destroy what you already know – it just might alter it slightly.

I never thought this way until I was forced to change Sensei due to moving out of my hometown, and then my home country.

A piece of advice my Sensei said to me when he heard I was leaving: “Do what Sensei says”.

I’m glad I have.

6 responses to “How many Sensei does it take to make a Karateka?”

  1. Alan Leslie avatar
    Alan Leslie

    Nice article I read somewhere that Chojun Miyagi actively told students to cross train .I started in Shotokan as a child never really felt it was me then at 30 decided to give karate a go again and Goju kata really blended well with me 🙂

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      All Sensei in Miyagi Sensei’s generation encouraged training with various Sensei, this was of course before Associations started to be the representative of the style. I think now Karate is having a renaissance with people seeking out other styles, arts and Sensei.

      Like

  2. Crystal Sandoval avatar
    Crystal Sandoval

    I am lucky in that my first Sensei encouraged his students to learn from other styles. He gave me a piece of advice that I apply to karate, but also life in general. ‘Things that are alive, change. If something stays the same, it will die.’ Knowing when to change can be difficult though.

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      Great advice and wise words!!! I have found that I changed perhaps before I ‘felt’ ready, but it worked out very well. Sometimes it’s hard not to feel a strong connection to a particular Sensei and to not want to "miss out" on future lessons.

      Like

  3. No matter how willing you are to learn, or how good you are at it, or how good your Sensei is, or how good your Sensei is at actually teaching, you come to a point where you can’t get any more useful teaching in the same context. I think it’s not just true about changing your Sensei, just changing the context of the class can make a huge difference. I was once teaching both a youth group and an adult group. The biggest kid in the youth group stopped developing in his class, so he changed over to the adult class. the same instructor (me), the same techniques, but he changed from being the biggest in the group to the smallest, and it made a huge impact on his learning.

    Like

    1. Benjamin Eayrs avatar
      Benjamin Eayrs

      That is a great point and well worth some Sensei taking note of. Whilst I was in Australia my Sensei had a class only for Black Belts and above. Not so it would be some exclusive club, but becuase then the advanced techniques and pirnciples could be taught. Some Dojo never want to take off the training wheels!!

      Like

Leave a comment

Who’s the Writer?

Ben teaches his students from over 20 years of experience in Karate, the latest in supplementary training, advice on lifestyle health, diet and nutrition, and a personal creativity towards applied Karate practice.